Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Reflection

A few discussions I have been privileged to be a part of lately have me thinking. The question I'm curious about is: at what point in my life did my opinion on social and political issues begin to veer in such a different direction than my local peers? I say local because this is the first time I've noticed it so distinctly.

I grew up in a home in where I was encouraged to think for myself, a place where I was free to question the reason behind a belief and where it was ok for me to form my own opinions. I don't know that I appreciated that when I was growing up. During my undergraduate studies I had a couple of wonderfully progressive and liberal professors that made it clear their intention was to challenge my beliefs. Seeing that was the first time I had really had to evaluate what I believe and how I see the world, I took pause to reexamine my positions on certain issues and wonder if the way I thought was gleaned from my parent's perspective, or if the opinion was my own. I think that some of the views I possessed at the time came from the fact that I was raised and attended school in a very conservative atmosphere and was never presented first-hand with very tough issues. The choices I made next in my life would give me these very opportunities.

The two things that I believe opened my mind further were first, marrying the man I did and second, making the move from Cedar City, Utah to Manhattan. Immediately I was aware, and a part of, racial and ethnic issues that hadn't ever been present in my life previously; I was attending school and working with people who weren't like me- meaning, they either weren't Caucasian, middle-class, heterosexual, Christian or conservative. I found the experience completely liberating and enjoyed most of all the mind-expanding conversations that Denten and I shared in this new open-minded society.

The school I attended as a whole presented wonderful new cultures, but specifically the topic of study I had chosen brought me face to face with new overwhelming experiences that required me to dig deep within me to find out how I was to react to them. Turning and running crossed my mind more than once being a solution as to how to avoid the uncomfortable that comes with new growing experiences, but enduring and eventually living them must have changed my core as I see that the profound beliefs I have acquired are sometimes significantly different than those I am often surrounded by.

I wondered if the difference was being a member of the church, but have come to the conclusion that that's not it. Denten and I have both seen a striking difference between the opinions and the level of judgement in the members of the church we call friends here in Phoenix as opposed to those we associated with in New York. Both groups value the gospel in their lives and protecting the sanctity of the family, yet go about living these beliefs very differently. After a discussion in Sunday School recently regarding charity, we wondered how exactly the judgement that we as a society claim to leave up to the Lord, yet clearly practice on each other regularly, fit together with the boundless charity we also claim. To love all men, yet not respect their rights equally; to mock a decal found on a car expressing a different lifestyle than our own, yet teaching our children that Jesus loved and treated everyone fairly and we should be doing the same; to serve others in our community as long as their physical appearance or language isn't different from our own.

I also wondered if the open-minded frame of mind I valued in my friends in New York came from the fact that by nature that place is incredibly diverse in all aspects of the word. The thing is, however, so is Phoenix! I can understand that a person who has been confined to a small town comprised only of white, christian, heterosexual individuals may not be aware of cultural issues outside of their own society, but in a city of this size and population, the awareness can not go unnoticed. It is the acceptance that is missing and I'm not quite sure why.

I suppose what it boils down to is this: Denten and I want our children to have a wonderful foundation in the gospel and an undeniable testimony of their Savior, and we want them to live as he did: open to all peoples and cultures this amazing world provides. I don't want to appear naive and say that there aren't dangers out there to be aware of, but within the walls of our home, criticizing the way another individual lives is not ok. I want them to serve with a happy heart and have that grow from the often obligatory reasons to a true desire to develop sincere relationships.

I feel the need to make it clear that I don't intend to discredit any particular group of people or the way they choose to live, and I don't claim to be free of judgement myself. I have been very blessed to continually be surrounded by true and loyal friends- friendship is something that I highly value and recognize that while there may be significant differences in opinion, there are also enough similarities upon which to have built a relationship. I'm not sure why Denten and I differ so much from others around us in the opinions we have about certain issues, and I suppose it really doesn't matter, but it has made for some interesting conversation recently in our home- and I'm always up for a great conversation!

15 comments:

Lindsay said...

I love it when you have stories like this! Something 'good' must have been said for you to write this one. I can hardly wait!

Amy said...

Oh great...did I cause this amount of reflection with my comments? :) I just love this post, really it has my smiling over here! I like your outlooks on the world...they push me to rethink mine and give me the confidence to be okay with my opinion.

bryn said...

i share many of your thoughts and it was nice to see your ideas expressed in writing. and what a great blessing to have a companion with which to share ideas and similar opinions.

Alicia said...

I too have similar thoughts in regards to the topics of which I think you are talking. I would love to expound more with you at some point. I think what it mostly comes down to is fear. What we don't know/understand scares us and makes it so that wanting to understand better isn't an easy feat.
I also feel that being in the enclosed circles that we live our lives in has a tendency to create a social 'bubble' that make prejudices, no matter what they involve, that much easier to follow.

Erin said...

well said.

Becky said...

I think I agree with you but since I wasn't positive exactly which views you were talking about the whole time I'm not sure :)

I do have to say that one of the main reasons we have chosen to send our children to Laveen Elementary School is because we want him to be in a classroom full of diversity (not 16 other white, LDS kids--although they're great people too--lol). Kids are so much better at being accepting than adults are!

Having Jeff be bishop for the last 3 1/2 years as given me a wonderful opportunity to experience some of life along with him. It is so possible to love the sinner without condoning or loving the sin (ie. homosexuality--they shouldn't be able to get married--the church is very clear on this--but that doesn't make them bad people at all).

Also, having my own father be in prison and see the reactions of people to this has been such an interesting experience for me (this month marks 9 years). I am deeply grateful for the Atonement and the example of the Savior...we all have so much to learn.

Sorry for the length of this post, and thanks for giving us something to think about, Amberly! :)

Nancy said...

great post amberly. i'm glad you're there as an ambassador of awareness :)

Anonymous said...

“Vice is a monster of so frightful mien, As to be hated needs but to be seen; Yet seen too oft, familiar with her face, we first endure, then pity, then embrace.”

- Alexander Pope

Kim said...

I totally appreciate this post Amberly. I think one of my biggest focuses is making sure nothing is fueled by hate. There's just way too much of that in this world, which is a lot of the reason I can't watch much political commentary. I love how living in different places opens your mind to others...maybe that's why we move so much. Heavenly Father must know what he's doing after all, huh?

The Silly Witch said...

This post was quite abstract, and I'm sure there's a very concrete story behind it. I agree with you, I'm not into criticizing other people, but I'm not afraid of using the bad choices of other's to teach my children. There is definitely a right and a wrong. And I'm not talking about whether it's right or wrong to own a motor boat or speed(hot topics in the ward my husband grew up). I'm talking about doctrinely wrong. Shacking up--wrong Marriage--right Stealing-wrong Honesty--Right We are blessed with the ability to choose between good and evil. And, as members of the church we are even more free because we KNOW good from evil. And I love it when I can talk to Pippi about consequences that come along with different lifestyles. Does this mean that I love people any less? No way. Can I talk about it in a loving manner? I truly hope so. We are so blessed to live in a nation and belong to a church that tries to help people in need, whether their need is physical or spiritual.

The Savior opened his arms to all sinners, and I want to be like that. "I know who you are. I know what you do. I love you; stop screwing up your life."

I, too, feel really liberated by the Manhattan experience. While I was shocked, occasionally, at comments made in Sunday School, my testimony grew, my roots deepening as I focused on doctrines, not just interpretations.

If only everyone could at some time in life find themselves in the minority! I truly felt myself in the minority in Manhattan as a stay at home mother of two.

I've never been to Phoenix, but I've heard that they have very interesting problems there. I'm sure your family can be a loving example.

Sandi said...

We too are exposed to much of what you refer and we fear that by pointing out the very things to which you alude, we too are judging. There is no simple answer to mans inhumanity to man. We strive to simply love and forgive, and love and forgive and when someone steps over the bounds of prejudice, we hug each other and forgive and love. Do we always handle it right? No, but we keep trying.

Kendra@My Insanity said...

I think from our conversation the other night, you gleaned that I am a political fence sitter. I guess I like to look at each issue individually an examine both sides before choosing my stance on a particular subject, and even then, be willing to look at things from another angle, if a new one is presented.

I have, on several occasions, felt uncomfortable in group settings (family or friends who are LDS) when assumptions are made that since everyone is LDS, we all share the same view on a political issue or candidate.

I think there may be more people than you realize with views similar to yours, that just don't talk politics (etc.) in these settings, because they think they are a small minority.

I thought it was important that during General Conference, Elder Ballard, while listing stats about the church mentioned that there were several members of the church from both parties serving in the US Congress. "And fifth, Mormons are well represented in politics and government. (In the United States, for example, there are 16 members in Congress, from both political parties.)"

I do think that travel and life experiences--mainly having faces to put with labels--shape my feelings about issues. It is much easier to blame or feel indifferently toward groups of people that are out of your realm of friendship or understanding.

I'm pretty sure I am rambling, but all of this is to say, 1) you are not completely alone and 2) good for you for not being afraid to own your opinions and beliefs, even when they are not popular with your peers (I tend to shy away from the potential for conflict.) I agree with Amy, that these discussions can only help people to think through things better and to define their own beliefs.

Patria said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Patria said...

Hot topic here! I just wanted to connect with you on the living in Manhattan bit- I loved every second of that experience. I will always remember my first sunday at church... i sat next to a woman my age who was also studying to be a social worker in the city and had just finished a dissertation on female characters in the Book of Mormon for a recent degree. I met a couple of women with hyphenated last names, others were wearing pant suits (minor deal, but you don't usually ever see it, is all), and many women were engaged in all kinds of pursuits. Not that these things represent something higher or better, but these different "ways of being" were really refreshing to me. It was ok for people to be making it through life in different ways, all striving for doing better. The best relief society lessons i've ever been in were in the Inwood ward there. there was more acceptance there. there's still a divide between us as church members in a church culture and the gospel...there's a difference. It's so common for the basic gospel belief of loving or forgiving all humans to be a major issue. We've all got our struggles, some struggles are more visible than others. a huge reason we wanted to live in hawaii with our kids is the diversity and acceptance factor. deeply important.

Unknown said...

i really enjoyed reading this today. i'm glad you took the time to put this reflection in writing!